The Flight and expulsion of the Germans: 500,000+ (sep 1, 1944 – mar 1, 1950)

Description:

The Flight and Expulsion of Germans (also known as "Vertreibung" in German) was carried out by the Soviet Union (under Joseph Stalin and Soviet military forces), Poland (Polish communist government under Władysław Gomułka, Polish military and militia), Czechoslovakia (under President Edvard Beneš, Czechoslovak army and armed volunteers), Yugoslavia (under Josip Broz Tito), Hungary, Romania, and the Baltic states, with approval from the Allied Powers (United States, United Kingdom, and Soviet Union at the Potsdam Conference) against ethnic Germans (Volksdeutsche) and German citizens (Reichsdeutsche) living in Eastern and Central Europe between 1944 (organized Nazi evacuations began, followed by Soviet advances) and 1950 (end of major expulsion operations), with an estimated death toll between 500,000-600,000 (recent scholarly consensus based on 1974 German Federal Archives study and German Church Search Service confirmed deaths) and 2,500,000 (upper estimates including West German government's 1958 estimate of 2 million, with some expellee organizations claiming higher).

The perpetrators also engaged in mass rape and sexual violence (systematic rape of German women and girls, particularly by Soviet forces), arbitrary executions and massacres (including the Horní Moštenice massacre where 265 Germans including 120 women and 74 children were shot and buried in mass graves on June 18, 1945, the Brno Death March where 20,000 ethnic Germans were forced to walk 40 miles with approximately 1,700 dying in May 1945, and massacre at Aussig/Ústí nad Labem where 763-800 Germans were killed in late May 1945), forced labor as deportees to the Soviet Union (approximately 200,000-250,000 died in Soviet forced labor camps), internment in concentration camps and labor camps (Yugoslavia established camps where over 50,000 Germans perished from deliberate starvation and murder; Czechoslovakia established 1,215 "internment camps," 846 forced labor centers, and 215 prisons where 100,000 reportedly perished according to Red Cross rough estimates, though only 6,989 deaths were confirmed), death marches and deportations in cattle cars without adequate food, water or sanitation (resulting in thousands of deaths from exposure, malnutrition, and disease), confiscation of all property, homes, land, and belongings (expellees typically allowed only one suitcase), looting by authorities and civilians, torture, arbitrary imprisonment, separation of families, forced displacement of 12-16 million people (the largest forced population transfer in human history), denial of citizenship and civil rights, retroactive legalization of crimes against Germans (Czechoslovakia's Law No. 115 of 1946 made "any act" against Germans legal if it aided Czech liberation, even murder, rape or torture committed before October 28, 1945), village and property destruction, starvation through denial of food rations, exposure to elements during winter deportations, and complete ethnic cleansing resulting in the near-total removal of centuries-old German communities from Eastern Europe (over 98% of Germans removed from some regions).
It has been labeled as ethnic cleansing by the overwhelming consensus of international scholars including historian Norman Naimark (author of "Fires of Hatred: Ethnic Cleansing in Twentieth-Century Europe"), historian R.M. Douglas (whose 2012 book "Orderly and Humane: The Expulsion of the Germans After the Second World War" extensively documented the atrocities), historian Alfred de Zayas (author of "A Terrible Revenge" and "Nemesis at Potsdam," former UN Human Rights official), the first UN High Commissioner for Human Rights José Ayala Lasso (who stated in 1995 that if states had reflected more on the expulsion of Germans, later ethnic cleansings "would, perhaps, not have occurred to the same extent"), historian Timothy Snyder, legal scholar Felix Ermacora (who called it genocide under the legal definition), scholars who describe it as "the largest forced population transfer in human history," Wikipedia and Britannica which list it as a major example of ethnic cleansing, and the 1992 UN General Assembly (which called ethnic cleansing in Yugoslavia "a form of genocide," establishing precedent for viewing such expulsions as potentially genocidal).

However, the classification as genocide in the strict legal sense remains contested, with most scholars preferring "ethnic cleansing" or "crimes against humanity".

The Institute for Research of Expelled Germans argues it constitutes ethnic cleansing rather than genocide because the primary goal was removal of populations rather than complete extermination, though they acknowledge at least 400,000-600,000 civilian deaths. No international court has prosecuted these expulsions as genocide or crimes against humanity, and as noted in the case Preussische Treuhand v. Poland, ethnic cleansing has taken place without legal redress. No countries have formally recognized the expulsions as genocide, though Germany has sought acknowledgment and some restitution, with limited success.

Regional breakdowns
Poland and former German eastern territories: Approximately 7 million Germans were expelled from territories annexed by Poland and the Soviet Union, including Silesia, Pomerania, East Prussia, and eastern Brandenburg. According to the 1974 German Federal Archives report, about 400,000 Germans died in post-war Poland and Soviet Kaliningrad, comprising 200,000 deaths as forced laborers in USSR, 100,000-120,000 killed by Soviets and allies in the 1945 military campaign, and 100,000 deaths from postwar incarcerations and forced labor.

On May 20-21, 1945, the Polish Workers Party Central Committee Plenum declared: "We must expel all the Germans because countries are built on national lines and not on multi-national ones." Władysław Gomułka ordered: "There has to be a border patrol at the border and the Germans have to be driven out. The main objective has to be the cleansing of the terrain of Germans, the building of a nation state." Up to 300,000 Germans living close to the Oder-Neisse line were expelled before Potsdam to present the Allies with a fait accompli.

Czechoslovakia: Approximately 3 million Sudeten and Carpathian Germans (95% of the total German population) were expelled. The West German government estimated 270,000 deaths in 1958, but a 1995 joint German-Czech historical commission concluded actual deaths were at least 15,000 and maximum 30,000. The German Church Search Service confirmed 14,215 deaths (6,316 violent deaths, 6,989 in internment camps, 907 in USSR as forced laborers).

Czech 2002 courts reaffirmed validity of the 1946 law retroactively legalizing "just reprisals" against Germans, preventing investigation or prosecution of any murder, rape or torture committed before October 28, 1945. This law remains valid today, meaning crimes against Germans during this period can never be prosecuted in Czech courts.
Yugoslavia: The remaining Germans were not expelled but turned ethnic German villages into internment camps where over 50,000 perished from deliberate starvation and direct murders by Yugoslav guards. By 1950, 150,000 Germans were classified as "expelled" in Germany, 150,000 in Austria, with 82,000 remaining in Yugoslavia (98.5% of Germans removed). Most survivors emigrated after 1950 or were assimilated.

Soviet Union: Nearly all 1,084,828 ethnic Germans in the Soviet Union (nearly 100%) were deported, with as many as 300,000 dying (30% mortality rate). This included over 400,000 Volga Germans (nearly 100% expelled), 150,000 Baltic Germans, and Germans from the Caucasus, Black Sea region, and Bessarabia. Stalin had already transported Germans from Crimea to Central Asia in 1941, establishing precedent for wartime ethnic deportations.
Hungary: Over 100,000 expelled, 300,000 displaced (88% total). The expulsion from Hungary was uniquely dictated from outside the nation, beginning December 22, 1944 when the Soviet Commander-in-Chief ordered expulsions.

Romania: 700,000 Transylvania Saxons and Banat Swabians displaced by Hitler, USSR, and emigration (91.5% of population).
Other regions: The Baltic states expelled 150,000, with deportations continuing through 1950.

The expulsion of Germans set a precedent for ethnic cleansing as an accepted tool of nation-building in the postwar order. The first UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, José Ayala Lasso, stated in 1995 that if states had reflected more on the expulsion of Germans, later ethnic cleansings "particularly those referred to as 'ethnic cleansing', would, perhaps, not have occurred to the same extent."

Added to timeline:

Date:

Images: