33
/
AIzaSyB4mHJ5NPEv-XzF7P6NDYXjlkCWaeKw5bc
November 30, 2025
1771907
143774
2
Public Timelines
FAQ

dec 27, 2013 - Another federal judge, U.S. District Judge William Pauley III in Manhattan, appointed by former President Bill Clinton, reaches an opposite conclusion, ruling that the NSA’s collection of phone data is legal.

Added to timeline:

30 Sep 2018
1
0
555

Date:

dec 27, 2013
Now
~ 11 years ago