9 h, nov 20, 2020 y - Depp v Heard Amber Heard Motion To Compel Documents & Responses to RFPs and Request For Sanctions HEARING

Description:

THE COURT: All right. Thank you all.
The objections to request for production one
through five are sustained. I find them to be overly broad, burdensome. As to six and seven, they are sustained on that grounds.as well and additionally on the grounds of vagueness. As to six and seven, the request to produce the documents requested in paragraph - in number eight is granted. The
request as to paragraph number nine is denied. The request with regards to the personal income tax returns is granted as to the return pages, not all the supplementary documents that are attached to them.

And, Ms. Bredehoft, I am-going to make a
comment to you. And maybe I shouldn't, but I am gong to, anyway, But you risk losing credibility with the Court when you come before the Court and accuse the other side of not following the rules.Yet, you repeatedly have tried to add matters to the argument docket that were not on the docket:
That, would be a violation of the rules.

You also send vastly overbroad requests apparently in the hope that they will negotiate something better than what you might have gotten had you sent a reasonable request in the first place. So that's part of the reason, that we have this on the. Friday docket; not simply because they are not giving you everything that you ask for or they are not negotiating in a fashion you wish for them to negotiate with. So I hope I am clear on that.
I am sorry I have to say it.

Added to timeline:

Date:

Images: