31 marzo 1919 anni - two men? Chernyak vs Cherednyak...

Descrizione:

Dubovik, in the name index he prepared for Volin,
tries to remove the confusion of Chernyak and Cherednyak. M.
Cherednyak appears as the head of the Berdyansk branch of the
Kontrrazvedka in the spring of 1919 and also as the chief of brigade
recruitment. And further on is a reference to A. Chernyak, who was
appointed already in March 1919 as chief of the recruitment section
and head of the Kontrrazvedka for Makhno's whole brigade. So,
according to this index both Chernyak and Cherednyak worked in
the Kontrrazvedka. Against this version there is one serious objec-
tion: none of the authors of memoirs about the Makhnovshchina
ever mentions these two important figures of the Kontrrazvedka
meeting each other. In short, the founder of the Makhnovist Kon-
trrazvedka, as a real kontrrazvednik, has up to now not yielded his
secret to researchers

Aggiunto al nastro di tempo:

Data: